Share Button

Thursday, August 7, 2014

Guardians of the Galaxy – Science Fiction or Fantasy?


THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN SCIENCE FICTION AND FANTASY

For some, this is a touchy subject. Some get downright fanatical about the difference. For example, Star Wars, they say, is pure fantasy while Star Trek is pure science fiction. The distinction between the two depends on whom you ask. Here's one definition:

"While science fiction draws on and extrapolates from what we know about reality and science, fantasy invents what does not (and likely could not) exist in our reality."

In science fiction, the science or technology needs to be integral to the plot of the story. As Asimov "If you can take the Science out of the Fiction and still have a viable story in another genre, you did it WRONG."

WHY THE DISTINCTION?

If we’re honest, aside from submission editors, the only people who care about the distinction between science fiction and fantasy are science fiction fanboys. So why do they care? Superiority. They want you to believe that science fiction is inherently better than fantasy. Any fantasy author or reader knows this is ridiculous. In fact, fantasy, as a genre, may be the older genre of storytelling. (source: The Difference Between Fantasy & Science Fiction)

Although many become fanatical discussing the difference, I tend to agree with  Guy Gavriel Kay:


I'd suggest that the search for sharp distinctions in literary categories is quixotic, except for one thing: 'quixotic' connotes something heroic as well as (probably) delusional. I doubt there's anything heroic in the category fetish. We need them, as consumers (and by extension, publishers - and agents and authors - need them as suppliers) and I've never agreed with those who suggest that a straight alphabetical shelving system for all fiction in bookstores in the way to go. Having said that, it seems only common sense to note that many books will blur borders, many authors will shift categories, sometimes with reckless abandon (to the chagrin of marketing departments everywhere), and many readers will endlessly debate definitions of categories.

- Guy Gavriel Kay (Guy Gavriel Kay - Official Website )

SCIENCE FICTION VS. FANTASY QUIZ

1. Is it Possible and Plausible?

Well, it's as plausible as anything in Star Trek or Asimov's Foundation series.There is no magic in Guardians of the Galaxy. Starlord has various technical toys but is essentially Indiana Jones with better tools. Rocket is the result of genetic manipulation and cybernetics.

The only elements that appears mystical are the Infinity Stones. In the movie they are forged by the interaction of multiple universe. So, in a sense, their origin is tied to our current understand on quantum physics. Sorta.

For more on the Infinity Stones click here: Infinity Gems by Comic Vine

2. Is the Science/Technology Integral to the Plot?

Absolutely. The central MacGuffin is a piece of technology. Every character in attempting to gain control of the Infinity Stone uses space-aged equipment to retrieve it. It could be said that one of the main characters is Starlord's mix tape, an old form of technology that keeps us tied to Earth even in the deepest part of space.

3. Does it Extrapolate from Known Science?

Every device we see is an extension of a currently existing one. It gives the movie a very grounded feel. Again, the only item that appears unimaginable is the Infinity Stone...and it is supposed to defy explanation.

IT SHOWS THE SCIENCE BUT DOESN'T FOCUS ON IT

One of my favorite parts was something subtle many may have missed. Throughout the entire movie, we are SHOWN that Starlord wears a small black device behind his right ear but it is never discussed in conversation. This is a nod to a universal translator that allows various species to communicate with each other. But no one talks about it because it is a common, everyday part of the culture. If you think about it, when was the last time you had a conversation with your friends about the technology and purpose behind a phone. Everyone knows what it is so no one talks about it. Similarly, in Game of Thrones, no one talks about the lack of moon in the sky because no one has ever considered there should be a moon in the sky.

The ear piece is an example of how worldbuilding done properly. It is there for the people that are looking for it but doesn’t get in the way of the story. Over-explanation can ruin a story. Need I mention midichlorians?The Real Problem with Midichlorians

Source: Midichlorians Explained

CONCLUSION

Based on these guidelines, Guardians of the Galaxy is best described as science fiction. However, you classify it, it is one of the best movies I've seen in years. I can't recommend this movie enough. If you haven't seen it yet, get off your computer, put away your phone, and go see it. You can thank me later.

LINKS TO GREAT ARTICLES ON THE DIFFERENCES BETWEEN SCIENCE FICTION AND FANTASY

Science Fiction & Fantasy: A Genre With Many Faces
The Difference Between Fantasy and Science Fiction
The Blurred Lines Between Science Fiction and Fantasy
Definitions of What Science Fiction Is and Is Not
Guardians of the Galaxy - Official Website


BOOKS BY M JOSEPH MURPHY:
Amazon: M Joseph Murphy on Amazon: Paperback and ebook
Smashwords: M Joseph Murphy Author Page on Smashwords
Kobo: M Joseph Murphy Books on Kobo

17 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Wow, Excellent post. This article is really very interesting and effective . I think its must be helpful for us. Thanks for sharing your informative.
    mentalist

    ReplyDelete
  3. Guardians of the Galaxy is just an obscene amount of fun.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Guardians of the Galaxy is right up there with The Avengers as a movie that delivers all the fun and action you want from a superhero adventure. 


    ReplyDelete
  5. The motley crew’s repartee makes for comedy that’s surprisingly consistent, yet freewheeling and sharp enough to pinball from Kevin Bacon to Jackson Pollock and back.

    ReplyDelete
  6. This article is efficient. Thank you for sharing it with us. I am visiting this blog on a daily basis and I am finding so much helpful article each time. Keep working on this and thank you once again. xnxx

    ReplyDelete
  7. “best-car-tablet-ipad-mounts” Are you there and wish to get the perfect companion for your long car journeys? Don’t worry because we’re here to help you. We have been examining the best car Tablet and iPad mounts that can be your entertainment system for your family during the long car journeys. Our mounts will provide your device steady support even when you’re driving on bumpy road. They’re simple to install and you will enjoy their swivel ball connection that will give you 360-degree rotation alongside with tilt function and you’ll watch your videos either in landscape or portrait modes. These are hassle free installation, just order your choice from here and you will have the best mounts.

    ReplyDelete
  8. votive candles - a wide collection of scented, unscented and coloured votive candles is available at ShopACandle.com. In different colours as Yellow, Pink, Ivory, Red, White, Green votive candles are also available in bulk.

    ReplyDelete
  9. New Home Construction ,swimming pool builder and hardscape design services in Charlotte, NC.

    ReplyDelete
  10. “Charlotte Counseling” Isaiah Counseling & Consulting in Charlotte, NC provided counseling services for women, men, children and couples.

    ReplyDelete
  11. “Anxiety meditation” Reduce stress and anxiety using meditation
    Best anxiety meditation videos on YouTube

    ReplyDelete
  12. “concord airport taxi” Concord airport taxi is a taxi company proving service in all over Concord area and Concord to Boston Logan International airport. It is operating its business since 1998 since a very good reputation. All of our taxi drivers are very much punctual and dedicated to provide service.

    ReplyDelete
  13. “posicionamiento seo” Guia de posicionamiento SEO paso a paso, si quieres tener tu web en el top 10 de google, no te puedes perder este articulo

    ReplyDelete
  14. “Web Design” WSI Provides high quality custom website design and development services in Harrisburg, Concord, Charlotte and surrounding areas.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Lego Serious Play is a process that is designed to hands-on boost innovative thinking and professional performance by using the context of play.

    ReplyDelete
  16. "scientific basis for magic" This website is a forum describing phenomena that cannot be explained by our current understanding of the natural sciences. This includes physics, quantum physics, and biology.

    ReplyDelete

Share Button